BEND, Ore. – Wednesday evening’s televised debate between appointed Deschutes County Interim Sheriff Ty Rupert and challenger Lt. James McLaughlin did not avoid the all-too-familiar cloud of allegations swirling around yet another campaign for the elected position.
But during the nearly hour-long debate on KTVZ News, the two men also did not engage in any direct personal attacks about what each other has been accused of. Instead, each defended their own record and perspective, rather than talk down their foe in the Nov. 3 election.
Rupert was appointed by county commissioners last year in the wake of elected Sheriff Kent van der Kamp’s resignation under fire and a possible recall effort after a state police standards panel voted that he lose his political certification for life for being untruthful.
Rupert said he’s worked hard to stabilize a chaotic department and emphasized fiscal restraint and equal application of the law. He pointed to “lateral hires” of officers from other agencies as a sign of an improved culture and image among law enforcement.
McLaughlin, on the other hand, said Rupert’s “interim” title has in itself made for instability. He also said the department needs structural reform, including community oversight and a broader focus on community issues, as opposed to a focus on arrest quotas.
Recent news reports have pointed to an independent investigator’s findings and a command staff recommendation that McLaughlin be fired for honesty and misconduct stemming from a citizen complaint about a SWAT callout in La Pine last February.
McLaughlin’s attorney has argued the investigation and proposed discipline were politically motivated. He reportedly plans to file a tort claim notice with the sheriff’s office, along with a federal lawsuit alleging violation of his constitutional rights.
Meanwhile, Rupert is the target of an ethics complaint alleging he may have used his public resources for personal campaign purposes. Rupert had the agency’s public information officer disseminate a media email about his filing as a candidate, later acknowledging it was a mistake stemming from his lack of experience in political matters.
In a lead-off question, McLaughlin was asked by KTVZ News political reporter Spencer Sacks about the independent investigator’s allegations of dishonesty, insubordination and misconduct.
“I’d say that’s a great question,” he said, “and every voter should be asking that question.” (Both candidates frequently praised the questions posed by Sacks and The Source Weekly founder Aaron Switzer several times during the debate.)
“I believe in accountability,” McLaughlin said. “I have no problem owning the things that I’ve done. … We have to build back public trust. But what I’m telling you is, the reason why I’m standing here today is because I am not dishonest. I am not untruthful.”
Rupert defended seeking the investigation: “I need everybody to understand – I don’t get to pick and choose when complaints came into our office. … As a sheriff, I knew the position this was going to put me in, but I had to do the right thing. And the right thing is to open an independent investigation, with an outside investigator, and that’s what we did.”
When Sacks asked a follow-up, noting “a lot of concern over the timing of this,” McLaughlin said he couldn’t speak to that, but added, “I’m in this investigation for the long haul. I’m in it for arbitration. I’m in it for years to come, to exonerate myself. Like I said, accountability is accountability. However, I won’t have the label ‘untruthful’ hung on me in an advantageous manner at this point in time, because it simply is not true.”
To Switzer’s follow-up question about “a lot of mudslinging in this race,” Rupert said, “Our office has been through some really difficult elections over the years, as we all know. And I was hoping that we could get through this election without that type of behavior going on.
“If you’ve been following my campaign, you’ll see I try to be very benign,” the sheriff said, adding while citizens “have to be thoroughly disgusted with what they’ve seen over the last several years with our office, and I recognize that.” But he said he tries not to pay any attention to social media and focus on his duties during the day, keeping campaign work confined to early in the morning and late at night.
McLaughlin noted he has posted the transcript of his interview with investigators on his website, and said he wants to avoid mudslinging: “I don’t know that there’s been direct jabs between us, and I will tell you that what I think this community needs to have healed is to hear me say that won’t happen.”
After a break, Rupert spoke of how he’s focused on rebuilding the battered department’s low morale “from day one” and to “settle the office down.”
But McLaughlin painted a different picture, saying “morale is unstable, at this point in time. I believe that any time you have three of the top ranks inside an agency as ‘interim,’ then you’re breeding instability at that point in time.”
He spoke of the need for “a community advisory committee, a steering committee of community members, small business owners, civic leaders that are inside the office, that steer those executive members in a direction that is more in tune with the community that we serve.”
Rupert’s response began: “For me, culture takes time” and he said the past culture that led to some people being treated better than others, “depending on who you were,” was “simply not acceptable.”
Asked by Switzer how he’s been working to reshape the culture, Rupert said: “You just care, right? You show up. … For me, the priority was just calming things down, by just trying to have a calm demeanor throughout the office, being true to who I am as a person.”
McLaughlin, meanwhile, pointed to “the things I’ve done to build camaraderie, to build culture within our agency, across the board.”
With a string of troubled campaigns, Switzer noted some in the community “believe this position should no longer be an elected one.”
McLaughlin said it should remain an elected position, as it is across Oregon and other states.”I think that if you’re looking to remove systemic corruption or those issues, having an appointed sheriff is going to be the same. … At least with a sheriff, the voters have a say.” Rupert agreed, saying he believes voters “have a right to pick their sheriff.”
The two men were asked if they were currently affiliated with a political party.
The interim sheriff said he’s a non-affiliated voter. “I have been most of my adult life. … There’s no room for politics in law enforcement. It doesn’t matter what political affiliation you have, the law should apply to every person equally.”
On the other hand, McLaughlin said that at various points in his life, “I’ve been a Republican, I’ve been an independent, I’ve been non-affiliated. I am currently a Democrat. And that isn’t because I’m confused. That is because who I am is not my political party.”
Asked for details, the lieutenant said he looks at social issues such as the homeless population, drug addiction and immigration – national and local issues as well.
“We will not arrest our way out of these problems that Deschutes County faces,” McLaughlin said. “Believe me, I’ve tried. … What we’re going to do is come together. Law enforcement is going to have an intelligence-based, modernized approach to law enforcement and public safety.”

Rupert was asked about what he’s done with a $72 million budget to ensure taxpayer funds are spent efficiently and effectively. The sheriff called it a key issue for him, noting that the sheriff’s office was operating under the uncertainty of three-year levies when he joined the sheriff’s office in 2005, before voters approved permanent property tax rates.
“I felt over the years that our office had been spending money recklessly with previous administrations.” Now, with diesel nearly $7 a gallon, “It’s hard for people to make a living. The sheriff’s office has to learn to live within its means.” He noted that in his first nine months, “we saved a little over $1 million that we were able to repurpose and put more deputies on patrol and more deputies in the jail, which is where we better serve our community.”
McLaughlin agreed, saying the sheriff’s office “must maintain a ‘zero-balance budget’ mindset,” not rush spend a surplus that arises in the spring.
With the urban and rural property tax districts at their rate limit, Switzer asked about how the sheriff can keep funding under control. McLaughlin said the county’s growing population – 25% in 14 years - calls for a new approach to law enforcement on issues such as recidivism.”
Rupert said that while he focused on cutting unnecessary spending, “Moving forward, there’s going to come a day that we’re going to have to go back to the taxpayers and ask for more money. I won’t do that until we’ve tightened our belts first.”
McLaughlin said he agreed with Rupert “100 percent” about not going to voters any time soon. He said the sheriff’s office should have a quarterly report to the public “to see where their money is being spent.
Sacks next asked the two men whether they think communities like La Pine and Sisters, which contract with the sheriff’s office, should form their own police departments instead.
“I would say for me, that is a hard no,” McLaughlin said. He said those more rural communities “love their local, specialized deputies, “and that means I don’t have to reinvent the wheel.” Rupert said it also was important to ensure in the budget that the cities “were actually paying the full cost of the deputies.”
“We’re not the only budget that’s tight,” the sheriff said. “The city’s budgets are tight. Everybody’s budgets are tight.”
Next up: the controversial automated license plate reader technology, and whether each candidate would like to see such surveillance expanded, stay the same or decreased.
Rupert pointed to a new body-warn camera system but said citizens have privacy concerns with the license plate readers. “I said, ‘absolutely not. We’re not going to be going to LPRs.” McLaughlin agreed, speaking of modernizing the agency’s law enforcement tactics and technology while still preserving constitutional rights.



Leave a comment:
No comments yet - be the first to share your thoughts!